Virtual Riding. Is it all it’s cracked up to be?

You’ve got to love it, right? Zwift, the first real virtual riding environment was a literal godsend for winter riding and making winter training better. I’d much rather be (mainly) indoors than having to constantly clean my bike and regrease bearings etc. So, Zwift (or Rouvy – my preferred option) is perfect, right? Uhhhh….. no, not quite. Let me explain!

Before we go any further, there are likely three main classifications of cyclists:
A) Those who ride only outdoors (OK people you can probably stop reading this article now!)
B) Those who solely ride indoors
C) Those who do a bit of both (probably depending on the weather or the training they’re supposed to be doing today – like me)

I suspect that the C option is the majority of riders, but I have no data to support this! Anyway, back to the article.

Erg mode.
I think this is probably my biggest bugbear of indoor riding. I understand why people use it – you pedal and the machine takes over altering power and resistance based on the workout you’re supposed to be doing and the cadence you’re riding at. Seems fair enough, and I’ll state that the workouts I hand out in our coaching plans provide this option.

But, when you ride outdoors, you’re constantly having forces act on you that change. You hit a hill and gravity acts on you, your speed slows and you change to a lower gear and yet it still feels harder. You hit a headwind and it’s similar, or a tailwind and the resistive air drag reduces.

Not only does the resistive force change (either air drag or gravity), but your power output changes with it too! Hit a hill and you’ll find yourself moving from say 200 W on the flat to an initial 300 W or more. Then you ease off a fraction because 300 isn’t sustainable and now you’re at 165 W, so you push a bit more. Eventually you find the rhythm and the swings in power are reduced but not eliminated.

Erg mode gives you a constant output. If you maintain the same power and same cadence, the resistive forces are constant. This misses the ‘stochastic’ nature of power changing as you ride outdoors. You don’t learn to cope with those changes and this can be a disadvantage when you ride outdoors.

Likewise, trainer difficulty is set to zero. So, you’re riding up the Stelvio pass on Rouvy or wherever and while you may be doing the same watts as if the trainer difficulty was set at 100% the resistive forces feel massively different. It’s like you’re riding almost with a broken chain and there’s nothing coming back at you. Again, there’s nothing wrong with that other than when you go riding outdoors and you suddenly realise that there are resistive forces and you’re not adapted to them – it’ll feel totally different.

So, what do I suggest? If you’re doing an endurance ride on Rouvy, Zwift, MyWhoosh, or wherever, then I’d generally suggest a mixed route, some flat riding, a few small hills, a few small descents. I regularly ride a stage of the TDU (I think it’s stage 4), flat for about 30-mins, an 8-minute hill, then some up and down, takes about 1hr15. Sometimes I do it twice! And, I just ride in ‘world’ mode (or whatever it may be called, I don’t actually know!). I change to a lower gear uphill and a bigger gear when I’m smashing it on the flat or downhill (a bit like real life!).

Then if I’m doing intervals it’ll depend on whether they’re short or long. Up to 30-secs or so I may use a flat loop, and if the intervals are longer then I’m probably doing them up Alpe d’Huez. I’ll change gear with fatigue and gradients, just like real life, again using world mode.

Recovery spins, I use a nice flat route and a low gear.

And, I do get why people use erg mode – it makes the workout ‘precise’, and means you’re not searching for the right bit of road to do your work on. And, if you do want to continue using it I’m fine with that. I don’t go nuts at the people I coach who use it!

Likewise, with trainer difficulty. And, even I’ve used this (:-O). When I used a cassette on my Tacx Neo it was a 12 – 25 cassette (which is what I use here where I live – it’s generally pretty flat), and I’d struggle riding Alpe d’Huez on the turbo trainer with a low gear of 39 x 25, so I’d turn down the trainer difficulty to 75%. That’s fine (I just wouldn’t use 0%). Now, I use one of those Zwift gear thingymejigs! (Mainly as the better half has a 12 speed cassette and I’m on 11 and it saves me having to change cassettes over).

That said, the main driver of fitness adaptations is the programme that you’re using and riding. You’re better off having a decent plan, following that, and doing the whole lot in erg mode rather than having a naff plan and not using erg mode.

If you need a decent plan so that you can be fit for spring then click here

Next
Next

How To Train For The Gralloch